Commission Meeting Agenda Item
Ordinance 2018-46 (Second and Final Reading) — An ordinance of the Town of lady Lake deleting and replacing Ordinance 2006-76 in its entirety and establishing a disciplinary arbitration panel (DAP) to adjudicate grievances in lieu of an arbitrator; setting the criteria for board membership; establishing hearing procedures; repealing all conflicting provisions, providing for severability, and establishing an effective date.
Staff Recommended Motion
Staff recommends approval of first reading of Ordinance 2018-46, an ordinance deleting and replacing Ordinance 2006-76 in its entirety and establishing a Disciplinary Arbitration Panel (DAP) to adjudicate grievances in lieu of an Arbitrator, setting for the criteria for Board Membership, establishing hearing procedures, repealing all conflicting provisions, providing for severability, and establishing an effective date, as presented.
The Town of Lady Lake and the Florida Police Benevolent Association (PBA) have worked diligently and in good faith to settle their differences.
It will promote the general health, safety, and welfare of the Town and its citizens to have an appointed Disciplinary Arbitration Panel made up of Lady Lake citizens to decide an aggrieved party's request to hear disciplinary matters for final adjudication instead of an arbitrator.
Ordinance 2006-76 Citizens’ Review Board was established on 11-16-06.
The first reading of this ordinance was approved by the Commission at their meeting on Monday, November 5, 2018, at 6 p.m.
The second and final reading of this ordinance before the Commission is scheduled for Monday, November 19, 2018, at 6:00 p.m.
Draft Ordinance 2018-46
AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF LADY LAKE DELETING AND REPLACING ORDINANCE 2006-76 IN ITS ENTIRETY AND ESTABLISHING A DISCIPLINARY ARBITRATION PANEL (DAP) TO ADJUDICATE GRIEVANCES IN LIEU OF AN ARBITRATOR; SETTING THE CRITERIA FOR BOARD MEMBERSHIP; ESTABLISHING HEARING PROCEDURES; REPEALING ALL CONFLICTING PROVISIONS, PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY, AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the Town of Lady Lake and the Florida Police Benevolent Association (PBA) have worked diligently and in good faith to settle their differences,
WHEREAS, the Town of Lady Lake finds that it is in the best interest of the Town and will promote the general health, safety, and welfare of the Town and its citizens to have an appointed Disciplinary Arbitration Panel made up of Lady Lake Citizens to decide an aggrieved party's request to hear disciplinary matters and to review all other disciplinary matters as agreed to by the PBA and the Town of Lady Lake,
WHEREAS, the Town of Lady Lake Staff and the PBA have proposed a Disciplinary Arbitration Panel to review such disciplinary matters for final adjudication,
WHEREAS, the Town Commission of the Town of Lady Lake held a public hearing to consider establishing a Disciplinary Arbitration Panel (DAP) to review and adjudicate disciplinary matters instead of an arbitrator and has determined that a DAP will serve the Town and its citizens well.
NOW THEREFORE, be it ordained and enacted by the Town Commission of the Town of Lady Lake, in Lake County, Florida:
Section 1. Establishment of Disciplinary Arbitration Panel (DAP), Criteria for Board Membership, and Hearing Procedures
The Town of Lady Lake hereby establishes a Disciplinary Arbitration Panel (DAP) to decide an aggrieved party's request to hear disciplinary matters and to review all other disciplinary matters as agreed to by the PBA and the Town of Lady Lake under the terms and procedures set forth in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein
Section 2. Conflicting Provisions Repealed
Should a Court of competent jurisdiction determine that this ordinance conflicts with any prior ordinance, this ordinance shall control and supersede the conflicting provision, if any.
Section 3. Severability
The provisions of this ordinance are declared to be separable and if any section, sentence, clause or phrase of this ordinance shall for any reason be held to be invalid or unconstitutional, such decision shall not effect the validity of the remaining sections, sentences, clauses or phrases of this ordinance, but they shall remain in effect, it being the legislative intent that this ordinance shall stand notwithstanding the invalidity of any part.
Section 4. Inclusion in the Town of Lady Lake Code
The Town Commission of the Town of Lady Lake intends that the provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Town of Lady Lake Code of Ordinances and that the sections of this Ordinance may be renumbered or re-lettered and the word "ordinance" may be changed to "section" "article" or such other appropriate word or phrase to accomplish such intentions.
Section 5. Effective Date
This ordinance shall become effective immediately upon final reading and adoption by the Town Commission of Town of Lady Lake, Florida as provided by law.
Passed and ordained by the Town Commission of the Town of Lady Lake, Florida, this 19th day of November, 2018.
Town of Lady Lake, Florida
Jim Richards, Mayor
Kristen Kollgaard, Town Clerk
Approved as to form:
Derek Schroth, Town Attorney
The Disciplinary Arbitration Panel will consist of five residents; three of which will be voting members and two will be alternates. Whenever possible, the applicants shall have had experience in labor relations, or human resources, or personnel management or similar related experience. A hearing shall not be held without three voting members present.
Criteria for membership on the volunteer DAP shall be as follows:
- Applications will be advertised by the Town Clerk’s Office.
- A DAP member must be and have been residents of the Town of Lady Lake for at least one full calendar year prior to their application for Panel membership and must maintain their Town residency during their term as a panel member.
- A DAP member must be at least 21 years of age.
- A DAP member must maintain residency within the Town limits throughout the duration of a three-year appointment term. In the event that a DAP member no longer resides within the Town limits of Lady Lake, an alternate member will replace them. The Town Clerk's Office will post a vacancy announcement for an alternate DAP position. The PBA will review applicants and select a new alternate DAP member with concurrence by the Town Commission.
- A DAP member must have no criminal record (an arrest will not automatically exclude membership, but appointment will be dependent upon the circumstances of the arrest).
- A DAP member must be able to pass the FDLE background check to include, but not limited to, criminal and in-house histories. Member must sign a Personal Inquiry Waiver for Background Check.
- A DAP member cannot be a current or former paid employee of the Town of Lady Lake, or a current or past Commissioner of Lady Lake.
- A DAP member cannot be related to a Town of Lady Lake employee as this term is defined in Article 27 of the existing contract between the PBA and the Town of Lady Lake.
- A DAP member must be willing to attend training.
- A DAP member must notify the Town Clerk's Office of any changes that may affect their membership qualifications or status. In the event, a DAP member has a conflict of interest in the grievance being heard, they must bring this to the attention of the Town Clerk's Office or at the beginning of the hearing proceedings in order for an alternate member to be assigned. Not complying with the stated rule will immediately disqualify member permanently from board.
- The initial empanelment shall consist of a staggered appointment time of one, two, and three-year terms. Thereafter, panel members shall be appointed for a three-year term with the possibility of additional term renewals.
- The PBA recommends candidates to the Town Manager for appointment and to the Town Commission for approval.
- The Disciplinary Arbitration Panel elects a chairperson and vice-chairperson from among the citizen members to preside over its proceedings.
If the matter has not been satisfactorily resolved at Step 3 of the grievance procedure, the PBA (or grievant if not represented by the PBA) will notify in writing to the Town Manager within twenty days after receipt of the Town’s Manager’s response to the grievant at Step 3, to have the disciplinary matter heard by the Disciplinary Arbitration Panel (DAP). Upon receipt of the notice the Town Manager or designee shall within seven days notify the Chair of the DAP to schedule a hearing within 20 days of the Town Manager’s notification. The Town Clerk’s Office will coordinate with the PBA or grievant and DAP to determine a date for the hearing.
The notification shall include the grievance as well as any relevant documents the parties may want to submit in advance to the Panel.
The hearing shall be conducted and decision rendered within 47 days of the written request by the PBA or grievant for a hearing. Reasonable extensions of this period may be granted by the Chair upon written request by either the Town or the PBA or grievant for good cause shown. Natural disasters are extenuating circumstances that are an automatic reason for extension beyond the 47-day timeline, and remains extended until normal operations are resumed.
No later than seven days prior to the hearing, the Town and the PBA or grievant must file with the Town Clerk’s Office, and copy the other party, with a list of witnesses each party intends on calling to testify at the hearing, and a copy of any and all exhibits that are to be introduced at the hearing. The Board will entertain requests by the parties to have the Chair send out certified letters to the witnesses urging their attendance upon application of either party to the Chair. The failure to list a witness or an exhibit will result in the exclusion of the witness's testimony or the exhibit, absent good cause shown as determined by the Chair.
All documentation provided by the Town and the PBA must be marked with a "T" for the Town or an "P" for the PBA, or “G” for Grievant. Each is responsible for marking all of their documentation prior to submitting to the Town Clerk Office.
Upon the hearing being convened, the Chair shall explain its purpose; identify him or herself, the other board members, the parties, and the representatives of the parties. The Chair shall ensure that the hearing is audiotaped in its entirety. The Chair or his designee shall swear in witnesses providing live testimony.
Each party shall be afforded the opportunity to give the Board an opening statement. After opening statements, the Town shall be afforded the opportunity to present its case through testimony or documentary evidence. The grievant shall then be afforded the opportunity to present his or her case through testimony and/or documentary evidence.
All witnesses shall be subject to cross-examination by the opposing party. At the conclusion of each witness' testimony, the Chair shall afford each member of the Board the ability to question the witness. Witnesses may appear by telephone only with express advanced permission from the Chair.
At the conclusion of the parties' presentations, both the Town and the grievant shall be afforded an opportunity to give closing statements to the Board.
The length of the hearing will not normally be more than one day in duration unless the parties petition the Chairperson for additional time. The Chair has the authority to grant time extensions.
The Rules of Evidence applicable to administrative proceedings pursuant to Florida Statute 120.57 shall be observed in this proceeding. The Chair shall make any rulings on evidentiary questions. The Chair shall have wide latitude to exclude from consideration evidence that is irrelevant. The Chair shall also exclude from consideration any evidence that was not used as a basis for the discipline by the Town, or any evidence that was not presented by the grievant in response to the discipline during the grievance procedure leading up to this proceeding.
The Chair shall have the latitude to run the proceedings in a manner that he or she deems appropriate to support the Board's efficiency and effectiveness. The Chair may eject any person who disrupts the proceedings.
Once the case is set for review by the three members, each must be present during all portions of the proceedings.
At the conclusion of the closing statements, the Panel shall deliberate in public and determine whether to agree to sustain or agree not to sustain or modify the disciplinary action taken. The majority decision of the DAP shall be final and binding on all of the parties and shall be the last step in an administrative remedy.
Both the hearing and the deliberations shall be open to the public pursuant to Florida's Sunshine Law. A Panel member is prohibited from speaking with another Panel member about the case in private.